On The Way is 'top down' not 'bottom up' - Church Times 20 May 2022

-

 A letter to the Church Times today from Save the Parish Cornwall's Neil Wallis, who points out that the Diocese of Truro's housekeeping exercise On The Way is very much a 'top down' rather than 'bottom up' process, despite suggestions to the contrary by the Bishop of St Germans, the Rt Rev Hugh Nelson.

The Bishop of St Germans, the Rt Revd Hugh Nelson, insisted that the diocese's On The Way (OTW) programme of cuts was 'an intentionally grass-roots led initiative'. The Bishops don't even see the final plans until they have been approved locally, he said. He has repeated this claim in in the media and publicly elsewhere  - which is a pity, as it is sophistry at best.

In December 2021, a report about OTW in Carnmarth North deanery synod detailed "discussions the Steering Group had had with Bishop Hugh earlier in the day" regarding what the Bishop called "the elephant in the room" - in other words, the difficulty of rolling out Transforming Mission locally while simultaneously implementing cuts.

On 28 April 2022, "Issue 10 - On The Way Update" reported: "[Rural Dean] Caspar [Bush' went on to repeat the answers that had been received by the Steering Group from (sic) their questions when they met with Bishop Hugh and Archdeacon Paul [Bryer]."

The document then details five specific instructions they were given to 'achieve the Deanery plan". There is not space here to spell out all the directives they received from the Bishop but one is particularly revealing: "There was a possibility for TM [Transforming Mission] money to be reset if necessary to achieve the Deanery [OTW] plan.

In other words, despite many diocesan denials, Save The Parish (Cornwall) is correct that the finances and operations of TM and OTW are inextricably intertwined, and there must be a full, honest and transparent audit of them to ensure millions of pounds are not wasted, many more priests are not axed, and our rural churches not closed.

What the above also shows is that Save The Parish is also correct that OTW is very much a bishop-led, top-down, not bottom-up process.

Neil Wallis

Save The Parish (Cornwall)



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Save The Parish Cornwall responds to Diocese of Truro statement

-
Image
Save The Parish Cornwall issues the following response to a regrettable statement by the Diocese of Truro published on its website on 5 March 2024. The Diocese misleadingly says that Save The Parish Cornwall is 'targeting clergy' and providing inaccurate clergy figures. Save The Parish Cornwall’s recent analysis of clergy numbers in the Diocese shows that there were just 39 priests for Cornwall’s 200 plus parishes and 300 churches at the end of December 2023 - according to figures supplied by Church House sources at the end of January 2024. A further 19 other incumbencies remained vacant. Stipendiary priests in Cornwall at the end of December 2023, and their locations: data supplied by Church House sources to Save The Parish Cornwall at the end of January 2024. There was, therefore, one stipendiary priest to 15,000 people: the population of Cornwall is just over 600,000. The number of stipendiary priests in Cornwall at the end of December 2023 was 39. Save The Parish Cornw
Read more

Save The Parish Cornwall calls for a moratorium on the Bishops' divisive On The Way plans

-
Image
Click here to read our dossier, published today to coincide with a meeting with the Bishop of St Germans, the Rt Rev Hugh Nelson, and Diocesan Secretary Rev Simon Cade. It contains testimonies from people across Cornwall who are dismayed and alarmed at the Bishops' On The Way plans that will change the nature of the Church of England in Cornwall forever. Bishop Hugh has the power to press the 'pause' button as the controversial plans attract national attention. We are urging him to have the courage to do so. How does healing of the church of Cornwall now happen?  Many have been badly hurt and threatened…. Can a safe place be created where all might flourish? We are calling for a moratorium, an increase in clergy numbers, a halt on the sale of parsonages and an end to oversight ministry.
Read more

Cornwall's Bishops in tailspin after BBC Sunday Politics coverage

-
Image
Cornwall’s Bishops have been stung by hard-hitting coverage on BBC Sunday Politics South West of their controversial On the Way cost-cutting programme which is cutting clergy numbers, merging parishes and threatening church closures. In a 1200-word statement on the Diocese of Truro website , and an accompanying letter to all churches, the Bishop of Truro, the Rt Rev Philip Mounstephen, and the Bishop of St Germans, the Rt Rev Hugh Nelson, complain about many aspects of the report ( click here to view the report ). The problem is, as so often with the Diocese of Truro statements, rhetoric does not coincide with reality. Truro complains (on the Diocesan website): “The report lasted just under five minutes but…. Much of the time was given to four speakers from a campaign group, three of whom have no connection with the church in Cornwall or with wider Cornish society." Save The Parish Cornwall explains: The four actually included two well-respected SouthWest MPs who are i
Read more